do 91% of camh's ongoing-ect patients have no memory problems or find them worth it?
“91% of people either don't have memory problems with ongoing ECT, or if they do, they decide the side effect is worth it.”
a guest, a psychiatrist said on PsychEd: Educational Psychiatry Podcast, 2026-11-01, at 56:48. hear it in context → the speaker cited: CAMH data.
the episode: PsychEd Case Rounds 1 with Dr. David Gratzer (at 56:48). we link the show's own page; we do not re-host audio.
first, the part that holds
camh does run an ect service with patients on ongoing (maintenance) ect, and a 2006 study from camh's own clinicians concluded that memory difficulties with maintenance ect were "limited and tolerable". published reviews also find that many people who report memory effects after ect still say they would have it again, so a figure that adds together "no memory problem" and "a memory problem I judge worth it" is not implausible.
what we found when we went and looked
we could not find a published camh dataset, paper or report containing a 91% figure. the only peer-reviewed camh maintenance-ect study we found (journal of ect, 2006, PMID 16633206) concludes that memory difficulties were "limited and tolerable", but its abstract gives no percentage and no "worth it" measure. the wider literature uses two separate measures, memory complaints and satisfaction, rather than one combined number: a bmj systematic review found at least one third of patients reported persistent memory loss, and a 2019 review found that between 36% and 98% would consider a second course. the 91% may well come from an internal camh audit, but without the question wording, the denominator or the dates, it cannot be checked.
assertion by assertion
| assertion | verdict | what the record says |
|---|---|---|
| 91% of people on ongoing ect either have no memory problems or judge the memory side effect worth it | unverifiable | we found no published source for this figure. it combines two outcomes ('no memory problem' plus 'problem but worth it') that published studies usually report separately, so no peer-reviewed number we found can confirm or contradict it. the question wording, the denominator and the follow-up period are all unknown. [1][2][3] |
| the figure comes from camh data | unverifiable | the only peer-reviewed camh-affiliated maintenance-ect study we found (2006) reports memory difficulties only in qualitative terms ('limited and tolerable') in its abstract, with no 91% figure and no 'worth it' item. an internal clinic audit may exist, but it is not public. [1] |
| context: how often patients report memory loss after ect in the published literature | confirmed | a bmj systematic review (2003) found that 'at least one third of patients reported persistent memory loss' and called a professional body's claim of over 80% satisfaction 'unfounded'. a 2019 bjpsych bulletin review reports subjective memory worsening in 28% of the largest sample (n=1,212). this is context, not the speaker's claim: someone who reports memory loss can still judge it worth it. [2][3] |
| context: how many patients judge ect acceptable despite side effects | confirmed | the 2019 review reports that 'the percentage of patients who would consider having a second course of ECT varies between 36% and 98%', and one study found that 73% were glad they had ect. that range is too wide to confirm or rule out a 91% figure at any single clinic. [3] |
both directions
for the speaker: camh's own published maintenance-ect study concluded that memory difficulties were "limited and tolerable" and that maintenance ect helped sustain improvement. the 2019 review's range for willingness to repeat ect (36% to 98%) includes clinics with very high acceptance. the 2019 review also reports that ultra-brief pulse ect, now widely used, is linked to fewer subjective memory complaints, which would push a modern clinic's numbers up.
against: no 91% figure appears in any record we could read. people on ongoing ect are a self-selected group: those who found the memory effects unbearable have mostly already stopped, so a figure measured among current maintenance patients will run high by design. the independent bmj review found that at least a third of patients report persistent memory loss and that high satisfaction figures depend on who asks and how. a separate 2026 cohort from another ontario ect clinic found that all participants reported substantial memory concerns at baseline, and 81% had dropped out by 12 months, which shows how much follow-up loss can shape these numbers.
what this cannot say
we could only read abstracts and review summaries, not the full 2006 camh paper, which may contain numbers that are not in its abstract. camh may hold unpublished quality-improvement data that matches the quote; our searches cannot reach unpublished data. 'memory problems' and 'worth it' have no standard definition across studies, so even published figures are not directly comparable. our verdict says the claim cannot be checked, not that it is wrong.
sources, each one fetched and read
- Centre for Addiction and Mental Health, Toronto. Clinical outcome and memory function with maintenance electroconvulsive therapy: a retrospective study. J ECT 2006;22(1):43-45. PMID 16633206 What we read there: maintenance ECT was effective in sustaining clinical improvement ... and memory difficulties were limited and tolerable. no percentages in the abstract. Fetched 2026-11-02 (HTTP 200). https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16633206/
- Patients' perspectives on electroconvulsive therapy: systematic review. BMJ 2003. PMID 12816822 What we read there: At least one third of patients reported persistent memory loss ... the current statement ... that over 80% of patients are satisfied with electroconvulsive therapy and that memory loss is not clinically important is unfounded. Fetched 2026-11-02 (HTTP 200). https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12816822/
- Subjective memory complaints after electroconvulsive therapy: systematic review. BJPsych Bulletin 2019;43(2):73-80 What we read there: Subjective memory worsened in 28% of the sample (n=1,212); the percentage of patients who would consider having a second course of ECT varies between 36% and 98%; ultra-brief pulse associated with fewer complaints. Fetched 2026-11-02 (HTTP 200). https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6472304
- Evaluation of short term and long term subjective and objective cognitive outcomes following ECT for depression in a naturalistic ambulatory setting: a cohort study. McMaster University / St. Joseph's Healthcare Hamilton, 2026. PMID 41788153 What we read there: 100 enrolled; all reported substantial subjective memory concerns at baseline; 66% lost to follow-up at 6 months, 81% at 12 months; no satisfaction or worth-it measure. Fetched 2026-11-02 (HTTP 200). https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC12957962/
speakers are described by role, not named. one sentence is quoted under fair use, with attribution and a link to the original at the timestamp; we do not re-host audio or video. nothing on this page is a reason to start, stop or change a medication. if you have the file behind anything marked unverifiable, the research board is where people can answer. adam