do people who quit alcohol and smoking together do better than those who keep smoking?
“there are studies showing that for people who are addicted to alcohol and nicotine products who give up both at the same time compared to people who just give up alcohol but keep smoking”
a guest, director of a dual diagnosis addiction clinic at Stanford (psychiatrist) said on Huberman Lab, 2026-11-09, at 19:34. hear it in context → the speaker cited: prospective studies.
first, the part that holds
the studies exist. prospective cohorts of people with alcohol problems keep finding that those who stop smoking too do better on drinking than those who keep smoking. in one, alcohol-dependent men went through a combined alcohol-and-smoking program, and the ones who quit cigarettes were about twice as likely to stay abstinent from alcohol for a year.
what we found when we went and looked
we read the studies. a 2023 japanese prospective cohort followed 198 alcohol-dependent men for 12 months after a 3-month inpatient program that targeted drinking and smoking at the same time. among baseline smokers, 59.0% of those who quit smoking in the first month after discharge stayed abstinent from alcohol for the full year, against 30.0% of those who kept smoking (hazard ratio for a drinking lapse 0.41, 95% ci 0.23–0.75). a us nationally representative cohort (nesarc, 5,515 adults with substance use disorders in remission) found that baseline smokers who were still smoking three years later had about twice the odds of relapse as smokers who had quit (adjusted or 2.02, 95% ci 1.65–2.47). that comparison pooled all substance use disorders and did not report alcohol on its own. all of these are observational. quitting smoking was not randomly assigned, so the studies show that the two go together, not that quitting smoking causes better drinking outcomes.
assertion by assertion
| assertion | verdict | what the record says |
|---|---|---|
| prospective studies exist comparing people with alcohol problems who also quit smoking against those who quit only alcohol and keep smoking | confirmed | a japanese prospective cohort (n=198 alcohol-dependent men, simultaneous alcohol and smoking cessation inpatient program, 12-month follow-up) and a us prospective cohort (nesarc, n=5,515 adults with remitted substance use disorders, two waves three years apart) both make this comparison directly. limit: the japanese sample is men only, from one program, with no control group. nesarc pools all substance use disorders. [1][2] |
| those who quit both have better outcomes than those who keep smoking | confirmed | japanese cohort: 12-month alcohol abstinence was 59.0% in new smoking quitters vs 30.0% in sustained smokers (hr for a drinking lapse 0.41, 95% ci 0.23–0.75; hr for a heavy-drinking lapse 0.47, 0.25–0.88). nesarc: continued smoking vs quitting gave adjusted or 2.02 (1.65–2.47) for substance use disorder relapse. a review of alcohol treatment studies found that 16 of 31 linked non-smoking or reduced smoking to better drinking outcomes. 15 of the 31 did not. [1][2][4] |
| the comparison is specific to people addicted to alcohol (and nicotine) | overstated | the japanese cohort is alcohol-specific. the nesarc quit-vs-continue analysis combined all substance use disorders and did not break out alcohol. in both studies, smokers were defined by smoking status, not by a diagnosis of nicotine dependence. a separate nesarc analysis of 9,134 adults in remission from alcohol use disorder found that current smokers had higher odds of alcohol dependence three years later (daily smokers: 54% higher odds, 95% ci 1.38–1.71). it compared smokers with non-smokers, not quitters with continuers. [1][2][3] |
| popular reading: quitting smoking causes better alcohol outcomes | overstated | every study above is observational. the authors of the japanese cohort list motivation and resilience as possible confounders. the alcohol-treatment review says the link 'does not imply per se that smoking triggers alcohol consumption'. the 2016 review cites a 2004 meta-analysis of cessation interventions in addiction treatment that found a 25% higher chance of long-term alcohol and drug abstinence. it also notes that observational studies often did not separate people who quit on their own from people who got treatment. [1][4][5] |
| context: quitting smoking during alcohol recovery worsens drinking | false | a 2016 review of 24 studies (2006–2016) found none reporting increased substance use after smoking cessation. 46% reported only positive effects and 17% reported no change. [5] |
both directions
for the speaker: two prospective cohorts make the exact comparison the speaker describes, and both point the same way. in the japanese cohort, people who quit smoking during a combined program had alcohol abstinence rates (59.0%) about double those of people who kept smoking (30.0%). the confidence intervals exclude no effect. in nesarc, people who kept smoking had twice the odds of substance use disorder relapse of those who quit. a review of 43 alcohol-treatment studies (10,296 patients) concluded that continued smoking may weaken the results of alcohol treatment. a 2016 review found no study in which quitting smoking made substance use worse.
against: none of these studies randomized who quit smoking. people able to quit cigarettes may also be more motivated, less severely dependent, or better supported, and the japanese authors name this as a limit. the nesarc quit-vs-continue result is not alcohol-specific. only about half the alcohol-treatment studies in the review (16 of 31) found the smoking link, so the evidence is not uniform. the japanese cohort is 198 men from one inpatient program with no control group and only self-reported drinking. the trial-level picture is more modest than the cohort numbers: a 2004 meta-analysis (cited in the 2016 review) found a 25% gain in long-term abstinence when cessation help was added to addiction treatment. we could not open the 2016 cochrane review of these trials, so we do not cite it.
what this cannot say
the quote is cut off mid-sentence. we checked the claim sentence as written ('better outcomes') and not any larger effect size the speaker may have gone on to give. observational cohorts cannot separate the effect of quitting smoking from the traits of people who manage to quit. self-reported drinking and smoking were not biochemically confirmed in the japanese cohort or in nesarc. we read abstracts and full-text summaries, not the raw data. the cochrane review of randomized trials (cd010274.pub2) blocked our access, so it does not inform this verdict. the 2004 meta-analysis figure comes to us through a later review, not from the original paper.
sources, each one fetched and read
- Nonsmoking after simultaneous alcohol abstinence and smoking cessation program was associated with better drinking status outcome in Japanese alcohol-dependent men: a prospective follow-up study. 2023. PMC10057780 (PMID 36989266) What we read there: 12-month alcohol abstinence 59.0% among baseline smokers who quit smoking in the first month after discharge vs 30.0% among sustained smokers; HR for drinking lapse 0.41 (0.23–0.75). n=198 men; limitations include no control group, self-report, and possible confounding by motivation. Fetched 2026-11-10 (HTTP 200). https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10057780/
- Cigarette smoking is associated with increased risk of substance use disorder relapse: a nationally representative, prospective longitudinal investigation. J Clin Psychiatry 2017;78(2):e152–e160. PMC5800400 What we read there: among Wave 1 smokers with remitted SUDs (n=5,515 total), continued smoking vs quitting: adjusted OR 2.02 (95% CI 1.65–2.47) for SUD relapse; all SUDs combined. Fetched 2026-11-10 (HTTP 200). https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC5800400/
- Cigarette smoking and risk of alcohol use relapse among adults in recovery from alcohol use disorders. NESARC waves 1–2. PMC4592419 What we read there: 9,134 adults with remitted AUD; daily smokers vs non-smokers at baseline had 54% higher odds of alcohol dependence three years later (95% CI 1.38–1.71); compared smokers with non-smokers, not quitters with continuers. Fetched 2026-11-10 (HTTP 200). https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4592419/
- Smoking as an outcome moderator in the treatment of alcohol use disorders. Review. PMC9651979 What we read there: 16 of 31 alcohol treatment studies showed non-smoking or decreased tobacco use linked to better drinking outcomes; 43 studies, 10,296 patients; the association 'does not imply per se that smoking triggers alcohol consumption'. Fetched 2026-11-10 (HTTP 200). https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9651979/
- Impact of quitting smoking and smoking cessation treatment on substance use outcomes: an updated and narrative review. PMC5140700 What we read there: of 24 studies (2006–2016), 46% solely positive, 17% no change, 0% increased substance use; cites a 2004 meta-analysis finding cessation interventions during addiction treatment associated with a 25% increased likelihood of long-term alcohol and drug abstinence. Fetched 2026-11-10 (HTTP 200). https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC5140700/
speakers are described by role, not named. one sentence is quoted under fair use, with attribution and a link to the original at the timestamp; we do not re-host audio or video. nothing on this page is a reason to start, stop or change a medication. if you have the file behind anything marked unverifiable, the research board is where people can answer. adam